| European Amateur Champions | 1972/3 |
|---|---|
| FA Amateur Cup Winners | 1959/60, 1964/5, 1971/2 |
| FA Amateur Cup Runner Up | 1954/5, 1965/6 |
| Isthmian League Champions | 1964/5, 1972/3 |
| Isthmian League Runner Up | 1963/4, 1965/6, 1973/4, 2014/5 |
| Isthmian League Cup Winners | 1976/7, 2014/5 |
| Isthmian League Cup Runner Up | 1986/7 |
| Full Members Cup Winners | 1993/4, 1997/8, 1998/9 |
| Inter-League Cup Runner Up | 1986/7 |
| Middlesex League Champions | 1912/3, 1913/4 |
| Athenian League Champions | 1952/3, 1955/6, 1960/1 |
| Athenian League Runner Up | 1928/9, 1932/3, 1947/8, 1948/9, 1951/2 |
| London League Division 1 Champions | 1912/3 |
| London Amateur Division Champions | 1913/4 |
| Finchley & District League Champions | 1910/1 |
| London Senior Cup Winners | 1963/4, 1968/9, 2008/9, 2011/2, 2014/5, 2019/20 |
| London Senior Cup Runner Up | 1935/6, 1950/1, 1954/5, 1958/9, 1971/2, 2005/6, 2007/8, 2010/1, 2015/6, 2021/22 |
| Middlesex Senior Cup Winners | 1933/4, 1938/9, 1955/6, 1957/8, 1959/60, 1964/5, 1966/7, 1971/2, 1972/3, 1973/4, 1985/6, 1998/9, 2001/2, 2002/3, 2003/4, 2017/8 | Middlesex Senior Cup Runner Up | 1924/5, 1930/1, 1944/5, 1946/7, 1956/7, 1960/1, 1970/1, 1974/5, 1977/8, 1983/4, 2007/8, 2008/9 | Middlesex Intermediate Cup Winners | 1964/5, 1966/7, 1972/3 | Middlesex Charity Cup Winners | 1921/2, 1926/7, 1935/6, 1944/5, 1945/6, 1946/7, 1947/8, 1953/4, 1956/7, 1975/6, 1976/7, 1978/9, 1984/5, 1987/8 | London Intermediate Cup Winners | 1962/3, 1964/5, 1972/3, 1975/6, 1979/80 | London Intermediate Cup Runner Up | 1963/4, 1968/9 | George Ruffell Memorial Shield Winner | 2001/2, 2003/4 | George Ruffell Memorial Shield Runner Up | 1998/9, 2002/3 |